Saturday, June 12, 2010

A good Ph.D. advisor...

... is a lot like Tim Gunn...of project runway.

Tim's stated goal is to give direct, honest and respectful feedback.

Wrapped up in that is taking the one-on-one relationship seriously and treating your grad students like young colleagues.

I've had friends who haven't been as lucky as me (A, in particular) -- as a result, I came to appreciate Dr. Advisor.

I'm sure Dr. A would have liked to get it finished more quickly -- but he also understood the demands on my time and he never set hard deadlines for me. I suppose I helped the situation by setting my own deadlines and generally meeting them.

Dr. A read and considered what I wrote. He politely disagreed with me and he realized that the dissertation is my project, not his. He told me early on that the point wasn't to write down what he thought -- rather, the point was for me to figure out what I thought and how it could be justified.

Dr. A also was willing to work outside his regular comfort zone -- because that's what I wanted to do. The fact of the matter is that the number of people in the country who could have supervised my dissertation is pretty low -- so, he told me that if it was going to get done, I was going to have to figure out the state of the field -- and he'd catch up. I hope that supervising my dissertation expanded his philosophical horizons a bit, even though I don't have any illusion that he'd have done that expansion on his own :).

The chances that I'll supervise grad students are quite slim -- but, I can take Dr. A's example and apply it to my own student and mentoring relationships. For that, I and my students owe Dr. A a large bunch of gratitude.

5 comments:

Meansomething said...

Coming in late to say CONGRATULATIONS and hooray! Safe trip back to BNState--or maybe you're back already.

Inside the Philosophy Factory said...

Thanks!

I'm home. I kind of floated across Iowa yesterday and got home in the early afternoon.

俊偉 said...

UT網際空間 UT網際空間 漂亮寶貝 人妖系列 交換夫妻 亞亞成人 亞洲免費 丹麥美女 中文搜色 清涼寫真 一業情貼 一夜留言 一葉晴貼 浣腸調教 泳裝美女 氣質美女 正妹麻將 歐美影片 歐美線上 檳榔西施 曖曖影片 日本寫真 日本女星 日本女郎 日本女生 日本同志 日本制服 撥霸美女 援助交易 接吻技巧 接吻影片 手槍美女 成人片觀 愛秀影音 想入非非 情人視訊 微風線上 影音聊天 影片交流 影片亞洲 廁所盜攝 已婚聊天 少年阿賓 小倉優子 小魔女拍 小說頻道 小說線上 寫真女星 娜美羅賓 女星寫真

Mary Sok said...

I think it is an obvious idea to get a good PhD advisor on your site when writing thesis paper. It would be great to have someone to run to if you think you face a blank wall. It would be also helpful that they can critic the paper so that you can see what can the paper weaknesses are.

agdrasil said...

I can only guess how hard it is sometimes to find and complete a serious task at university. As a former student every man can name several logical reasons for youngsters to look for best company writing term papers online during their studies. We hire some good writing services to perform my scheduled tasks and make a good arrangements of my own ideas.